Rohit Sharma this, Virat Kohli that but what about Shubman Gill’s horrible overseas numbers in Tests?

When Shubman Gill dominated all the ODI batting charts in 2023, it looked like we would witness a ‘master-apprentice’ duo for the first time since Sachin Tendulkar and Virat Kohli. After all, Virat Kohli, in his second wind as an ODI batter, was a perfect “master” to Gill’s youthful but high-ceiling potential. But fast forward now; Gill has not touched the heights we all thought he would, almost 6 years after his debut. Many debated that Gill was unfairly dropped in Melbourne but the youngster turned out to be a disappointment in this BGT series.

High hopes dashed in BGT

We are amidst a high-octane Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT). Gill has now been part of three of these historic series, including the famous 2020/21 triumph Down Under. He even played a vital role in that rubber, hammering a mach-winning 91 in the fourth innings of the Gabba Test. However, since then, his numbers have dwindled down massively. Kudos to Gill for making the most of the opportunities he got in India’s home season. He played a total of 9 Tests at home since 2024, racking up three hundreds and as many fifties.

However, since his ton against Bangladesh in the second innings in Chennai, Gill has endured a lean patch. In fact, since then, he has made just 282 runs across nine innings at 25.63. Mind you, this period includes 5 innings at home too. Gill’s poor form has continued with him in Australia as well, with him mustering just 93 runs at 18.60 in five innings. To his credit, Gill missed a vital few days in his preparation for the Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT).

He had to sit out from the opening Test in Perth before fully recovering from a finger injury he got while playing a match simulation against India A. Regardless, Gill got to play the practice game against the Prime Minister’s XI, where he even made a 50. But when the real deal came, Gill faltered—both in Adelaide and in Brisbane. He was dropped in Melbourne and made his way when Rohit Sharma “dropped himself out” in Sydney.

There’s no second thought that all 12 of Gill’s boundaries have looked like a million dollars in the ongoing series, but his technique has let him down. Predominantly an upright player who likes pace on the ball, Gill has and will find it hard to weather the early storm against Australian pace attack. With some lateral movement and now wobble seam, Gill’s “frontfoot” mindset might make it difficult for him in these conditions.

Latest on Cricket

Virat Kohli’s troubles mirror Shubman Gill’s struggles

Another player who has faltered “technically” Down Under has been Gill’s idol Virat Kohli. The modern-day master just hasn’t left balls outside off-stump—his long-term ailing conflict. His refusal to leave balls in the channel outside off continues to undermine his innings and, by extension, it hugely affects the team as well. The likes of Mitchell Starc and Scott Boland have cherished bowling at Kohli, who has ended his BGT as well in similar fashion. Kohli’s poor Test form is a mystery to none now, with him averaging just 7.00 in 1st innings since 2024.

While Kohli has surely received huge flak from his critics over his technique, one should not forget that the onus of making runs wasn’t just on Kohli. Gill, who has had an awful last three years overseas, had to make amends but he couldn’t. Hear this: Since his 91 at Gabba in BGT 2021, Gill has averaged a mere 17 (255 runs in 15 innings) while batting in SENA countries. His numbers are extremely poor considering Pujara, who got replaced by Gill, has 494 runs at 26 in the same period in similar conditions. Even Shardul Thakur has better numbers than Gill in this period.

Shubman Gill Test record since 2024: Home & Away

2024	Mat	Inns	Runs	HS	Ave	100	50	4s	6s
Home	9	17	760	119*	50.66	3	3	73	18
Away	4	7	139	36	19.85	0	0	15	0

Indian batters in SENA ft. Gill

Player	Inns	Runs	HS	Ave	100	50
KL Rahul	27	930	129	35.76	3	4
Virat Kohli	30	892	100*	30.75	1	4
Rishabh Pant	26	835	146	33.4	2	3
Rohit Sharma	21	581	127	30.57	1	2
Ravindra Jadeja	19	501	104	26.36	1	2
Cheteshwar Pujara	20	494	91	26	0	4
Ajinkya Rahane	17	444	89	26.11	0	3
Yashsavi Jaiswal	14	441	161	33.92	1	2
Nitish Reddy	9	298	114	37.25	1	0
Shardul Thakur	15	258	60	17.2	0	3
Shubman Gill	15	255	36	17	0	0
Jasprit Bumrah	28	212	34*	10.09	0	0

Shubman Gill’s struggles in overseas conditions are overshadowed by the spotlight on Virat Kohli’s slump, but they warrant equal attention. Rohit Sharma gave a superb account of leadership by dropping himself, despite being the highest run-getter for India since the start of the ICC World Test Championship (WTC). If Gill aspires to be a cornerstone of India’s batting lineup, he must adapt and deliver in challenging conditions. The comparisons to Tendulkar and Kohli will remain distant dreams unless Gill addresses his vulnerabilities and finds consistency beyond home soil.