No Impact Player in IPL? BCCI puts hold on controversial rule in testing event Mushtaq Ali Trophy

The ever-so controversial ‘Impact Rule’ is under scanner once more. It seems like the the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) had to provide their decision on the rule for the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy (SMAT) 2025. However, they have put their decision on hold, a likely prospect that this ‘Impact sub’ rule might not be in for next year’s Indian Premier League (IPL) as well.

BCCI’s letter for Impact Player Rule

BCCI has announced a postponement in its decision regarding the implementation of the Impact Player rule for India’s premier domestic Twenty20 competition.

The BCCI said in a letter to the state associations that it will release information later on the terms of play for the domestic men’s Twenty20 competition, including the Impact Player rule. It is anticipated that the choice will be made within a few days. The BCCI has given the states advice on how to divide the match money in the interim.

“With regards to Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy, if a team decides to use the ‘Impact Player’ during the match, he will be eligible for 100 per cent match fees over and above the playing XI,” the BCCI stated.

Key Points by BCCI

1. Decision Delayed: The BCCI has informed state associations that details on the playing conditions, including the Impact Player rule, will be provided at a later date. The decision is expected within a few days.
2. Match Fee for Impact Players: If implemented, the 12th member of the squad, serving as the Impact Player, will be entitled to a full (100%) match fee, equivalent to that of the playing XI.
3. Decision-Making Process: The matter is currently under consideration by BCCI secretary Jay Shah, who has previously approved playing conditions for other competitions.

Additional BCCI announcements:

1. Match Fees for Squad Members: The BCCI has clarified that 15 players will be eligible for match fees, with the playing XI receiving 100% and the remaining four entitled to 50%.
2. National Players in Domestic Cricket: If a Team India cricketer is deputed by the BCCI to participate in domestic cricket, they will be eligible for match fees based on their playing or non-playing status, in addition to the 15-player squad.

Impact Player rule!

The Impact Player rule has significantly alter the dynamics of T20 cricket in India. It allows teams to substitute a player during the match, potentially providing more strategic options and increasing the importance of bench strength. However, it also raises concerns about the traditional aspects of the game, particularly the value placed on all-round skills.

The BCCI’s cautious approach in implementing this rule reflects the significance of the decision. By postponing the announcement, the board is likely taking time to consider all aspects and potential consequences of the rule change. Many players have shown their discontent over the rule and the matter was also discussed in the recent BCCI & IPL owners meeting.